If the SYN gets through, then the server knows that the client can send packets to it, because, well, it just happened. But that doesn't prove that the server can send packets back: clients can send SYNs for lots of reasons. This is the second step of the handshake. So it sends back an ACK: just a plain ACK this time, because it doesn't need proof anymore that its packets can get through. This is the final step of the handshake: the client now knows that packets can go both ways, and that the server is just about to figure this out because it knows the ACK will go through.
Once that ACK gets through, now the server knows that it can send packets to the client. It also knows that the client knows this, so it can start sending data right away. The handshake is complete. We have a good channel. Well, strictly speaking, we can't be certain we have a good channel.
Just because this sequence of packets got through does not strictly guarantee that others will. We can't prove that without sending an infinite number of SYNs and ACKs, and then nothing else would ever get done, so that's not really a practical option.
But in practice, three steps turns out to be good enough for most purposes. Actually, a 3-way handshake isn't the only means of establishing a TCP connection.
TCP connection is bidirectional. What this means is that it actually is a pair of one-way connections. Two simplex connections form one duplex TCP session, agree? So logically there are four steps involved; but because SYN and ACK flags are different "fields" of TCP header, they can be set simultaneously - the second and the third steps of the four are combined, so technically there are three packet exchanges.
Each simplex half- connection uses 2-way exchange, as you proposed. It is not necessary at all. The previous answers just describe the system without discussing the need for random sequence numbers etc. The original question was about the design of TCP itself -- obviously if you use the TCP protocol then you need three messages because that is the protocol. But why was TCP designed that way in the first place?
I believe the original idea was that there was no distinction between clients and servers. Both knew the other's ports in a bidirectional manner, and either could start the conversation. And that required Syns etc. But this is not, of course, how it is used today.
The server listens on a well known port and does and "accept", the client port number is ephemeral. I do not even think it is possible for a server waiting on an "accept" to send a request to another on the same client port number in normal operating systems. Note that this is about bidirectional initiation of the connection, which is never done today.
That is quite different from sending bidirectional messages down a connection once established. But Http 1. So that protocol includes its own session reuse mechanism which runs on top of Http 1. Such is the way with software.
Fudges on kludges which when combined, produce an acceptable result. After reading answer of Eddie accepted as correct , there are still question why 1st host can not assign both ISN's with random numbers and 2nd just accept it.
Real reason of using 3-way handshake is to avoid half-connections. As a result Server has connection that will never be closed. For client: actually a two-way handshake is enough because it sends to server and server sends back. For server: three-way handshake is needed since the server needs to know the message it sends back to client second message is successful. The third message from client proves that the server's message second message is successful so the third message is needed. Sign up to join this community.
The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group.
Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more. Why do we need a 3-way handshake? Why not just 2-way? Ask Question. Which book? Add a comment. Active Oldest Votes. To establish a connection, the three-way or 3-step handshake occurs: SYN: The active open is performed by the client sending a SYN to the server. Improve this answer. Richmond S. Richmond What changes if the 3rd ACK is not there?
See if reverse channel is unreliable, then the connection is not going anywhere as it is. The sequence numbers can be exchanged with two messages.
Reliable transmission is misunderstood. The connection may get dropped, no? The definition of reliability with regards to TCP is not about connection stability as that is out of the control of the protocol. It is that messages will reliably arrive at the destination application in order. So why the third ack is needed. If we omit that, the sequence number scheme can still guarantee in order delivery — Amit. Because three segments are sent between the two hosts, this connection-establishment procedure is often referred to as a three-way handshake In other words, A does not need to wait for the three-way handshake to complete before sending data.
Community Bot 1 1 1 silver badge. Josiah Yoder Josiah Yoder 2, 4 4 gold badges 30 30 silver badges 50 50 bronze badges. Sagar Chand Sagar Chand 6 6 silver badges 16 16 bronze badges. Sign up or log in Sign up using Google. Sign up using Facebook. Sign up using Email and Password. When many people think or try to answer this question in fact concerns are placed in a three-way handshake is three times above, this is really important, but if you re-examine this question, we have to "What is the connection" really clear?
Only you know the definition connections , we can try to answer why the TCP three-way handshake to establish a connection needs. RFC - Transmission Control Protocol document very clearly defines what the TCP connection, we briefly summarize: to ensure information reliability and flow control mechanisms, including Socket, serial number, and size of the window is called the connection.
View Image. Therefore, the TCP connection is established communication between the parties need to reach a consensus on the three kinds of information described above, a pair of Socket connection by the Internet address, and port identifier, the window size is mainly used for flow control, last sequence number is used to track communication initiation packet number sent by the receiving party may acknowledge successful reception of a data packet by the sequence number to the sender.
Here, we converted the original question, "Why do you need before you can initialize Sockets, window size and the initial sequence number by three-way handshake? This article will introduce the following aspects Why do we need to initialize Sockets, window size by three-way handshake, the initial sequence number and to establish a TCP connection:.
The first of these arguments is to choose the most primary reason for using TCP three-way handshake, compared to several other reasons are secondary reasons, we are here to discuss them just to get the whole perspective richer by understanding this and many interesting design decisions. RFC - Transmission Control Protocol fact, pointed out the primary reason for using a three-way handshake TCP connection - in order to prevent confusion of history repeating connection initialization caused both sides to prevent the use of TCP protocol for communication to establish a connection error.
Imagine this scenario, if the communication of both the number of communications only twice, once issued after the sender's request to establish a connection once it is no way to withdraw the request, if the complex or in poor network conditions network, the sender sends continuous repeated request to establish a connection, TCP connection is established only if the two communications, so the recipient can choose to accept or reject the request initiated by the sender, it is not clear that a request is not due to network congestion early in the expired connections.
Use three-way handshake and RST control messages to establish whether ultimate control over connected to the sender because only the sender has enough context to determine whether the current connection is wrong or out of date, which is the TCP three-way handshake to establish a connection using the most main reason. Another use of three-way handshake important reason is that both sides need to initialize the communication sequence number used to send a message as a reliable transport layer protocol, TCP need to build a reliable transport layer in an unstable network environment, network uncertainty may result in loss of data packets and the order is reversed and other issues, common problems may include:.
In order to solve the above-mentioned possible problems, TCP protocol requires the sender add the "serial number" field in the data packet, the packet with the corresponding serial number, we can:.
Furthermore, the network is a distributed system in which there is not a global clock for counting, and the TCP sequence number may be initialized through different mechanisms, the TCP connection as a receiver can not judge each other we came initialization sequence number is out of date, so we need to judge handed over to the other side, the serial number to determine the originator of the TCP connection can be issued by saving the connection has expired, if the recipient to save and to determine the serial number is not realistic, it also once again reinforces the ideas presented in the previous section - to avoid wrong connection initialization history.
When we talk about the number of established TCP connection requires communication, we often cling to why the communication three times before they can establish a connection, instead of twice or four times; discuss the use of more number of communications to establish a connection often does not make sense, because we can always use more number of communications to exchange the same information , so use four, five or more times to establish the connection are technically entirely achievable.
This increase in the number of TCP connections communication problems often do not have the need for this discussion, we seek actually to complete the exchange of information with fewer number of theoretical boundary communication, which is why we have repeatedly stressed in the two sections the use of "two-way handshake" is no way to establish a TCP connection, using a three-way handshake to establish a minimum number of connections needed.
We discuss in this article why the TCP three-way handshake to establish a connection to go through, before a detailed analysis of this question, we first rethink what exactly is a TCP connection, RFC - Transmission Control Protocol - IETF Tools for TCP connection has a very clear definition - used to ensure data reliability and flow control mechanism, including the Socket, sequence number and a window size.
0コメント